Dominant Dilemma: When Pleasure and Guilt Collide in BDSM

We’re no longer complete novices. We’ve at last discovered a group of people who understand our interest in the “kink world.” We’ve been exploring this realm secretly and clumsily for years, not realizing there’s an entire community out there with similar interests – some even more adventurous! We’re not alone. Moreover, many of these people seem quite decent, intriguing, and “ordinary.” A whole new universe has unfolded before us.

We’re excited about our first play session. We’ve met an attractive, experienced individual who shares our interests and is eager to participate. It’s thrilling! We may be a bit nervous, hoping to get things “right,” but we’re mostly overjoyed to have the support and acceptance of others who speak our language. We no longer need to conceal our desires or fear being judged as bad people.

Our initial play session goes exceptionally well! The flogging lessons have paid off, and our play partner is supportive and understanding of our hesitations and anxieties. It feels incredible to wield a flogger against someone’s gorgeous rear! It’s as sensual as we had imagined, and also tender and intimate, fostering a deep connection. We feel more empowered than ever before. Our entire being vibrates with new potential. We feel seen, strong, invigorated, and liberated. It’s an amazing sensation!

After our partner leaves to use the restroom, we prepare for some cozy, tender aftercare. Suddenly, a fleeting thought crosses our mind, almost imperceptible.

“What’s wrong with you? You’re celebrating the fact that you just made someone’s back black and blue. You HIT someone, repeatedly, and it aroused you. You enjoyed it. Sick jerk.”

Your mind seizes up, and a numbness takes over, potentially leading to regret and shame. You question yourself – what kind of twisted person finds pleasure in inflicting pain on others?

crash The euphoria evaporates into a haze of dark concern, suggesting that no healthy person should feel this elated after what you just did. This cloud may hover or spiral further downward, dragging us along and causing us to become irritable, distant, worried, and embarrassed. It makes us doubt every joyful, empowering moment we just experienced. Your partner returns to the room, smiling at first, but then puzzled when they sense the intimate magic has somehow soured.

“We no longer need to conceal our desires or fear being judged as bad people.”

This is just one manifestation of Top guilt. It’s not pleasant, and it’s not fun. Not everyone experiences it, but many do, particularly when we’re new to the scene and still shedding the shame and secrecy we’ve carried for years. We may understand logically that guilt and shame are unwarranted, but these emotions can be deeply rooted in our psyche and surface at the most inconvenient times, bursting our bubble.

Even after years of engaging in ethical BDSM practices with clear consent, open communication, and honesty, residual guilt and shame can suddenly emerge and prod us where it hurts, suggesting we have no right to take pleasure in causing another’s pain or discomfort. Old beliefs can be persistent, especially if we’ve been chastised by someone significant in our lives – a parent, teacher, or romantic partner. Many of us acquire some degree of shame simply because no one around us discusses or engages in these activities. If we don’t see our interests reflected in our surroundings, we may believe we’re unique and flawed.

I don’t have a quick solution for Top guilt. However, if you notice it affecting you, there are several strategies that may help alleviate it, either permanently or as it arises. Here are a few techniques that have worked for me, although there are likely other options I haven’t considered.

Strategy 1: Harness the Power of Partner Feedback

One of the most effective remedies for Top guilt is receiving positive feedback from your submissive partner. Hearing how wonderful you made them feel through your skillful humiliation and/or sadistic creativity can be incredibly reassuring. You can address it directly by discussing it with your partner and requesting feedback as part of (/how-to-dominate-a-submissive/) aftercare. Alternatively, you can approach it indirectly by asking for post-scene feedback as part of your aftercare for them. Ideally, they will provide you with the positive feedback you need.

Being reminded that what you enjoy doing is also something your partner genuinely enjoys receiving can effectively counteract any negative thoughts.

“Hearing how wonderful you made them feel through your skillful humiliation and sadistic creativity can be incredibly reassuring.”

Practical steps for getting useful feedback:

1. Ask specific questions. Don’t just say “How was it?” Ask “What moments felt most intense for you?” or “Which parts of the scene really worked for you?”

2. Create a feedback ritual. Make partner feedback a standard part of your aftercare routine, not an occasional request when you’re feeling insecure.

3. Use written check-ins. Some submissives express themselves better in writing. Consider a shared journal or message thread where they can reflect post-scene.

4. Request examples. Ask your partner to describe specific sensations or emotions they experienced during the scene. Concrete details hit differently than vague praise.

5. Time it right. Some people need space before they can process. Give your partner 24-48 hours, then ask for their reflections when subspace has fully cleared.

Strategy 2: Connect with Your Tribe

In addition to obtaining positive feedback from your play partner, connecting with others who share your BDSM interests can be immensely helpful. Participating in discussions about shared kinks, either in-person or online, can provide comfort for those struggling with residual shame. In some cases, you might even be able to discuss your experiences with shame explicitly, although not everyone may be open to such conversations.

“The flogging lessons have paid off, and our play partner is supportive and understanding of our hesitations and anxieties.”

Here’s how to build your support network:

1. Join online Dominant communities. Forums like FetLife, Reddit’s BDSM communities, or Discord servers offer spaces to discuss challenges anonymously.

2. Attend local munches. These casual, public meetups are perfect for meeting experienced Dominants who’ve navigated similar struggles.

3. Find a mentor. Look for an experienced Dom who’s willing to share their journey, including how they dealt with guilt or shame early on.

4. Read books on BDSM. Including instructional guides, theoretical and psychological texts, and even spiritual kink material can be enlightening. Seeing your experiences reflected in published work normalizes your feelings.

5. Attend workshops. Learn from and engage with experienced, knowledgeable individuals you can look up to. Watching confident Dominants discuss their practice reinforces that your desires are valid.

6. Join a discussion group for Dominants. A local group can provide a safe space to discuss shame and other challenges without judgment.

7. Seek counseling from a kink-friendly therapist. This may be beneficial if guilt and shame are particularly troublesome or rooted in deeper trauma.

Strategy 3: Reframe Your Internal Narrative

The voice in your head that whispers “sick jerk” is operating on outdated programming. It’s time to update your mental software.

Cognitive techniques to silence the shame spiral:

1. Challenge the thought immediately. When guilt strikes, counter it with facts: “My partner explicitly consented. They communicated throughout. They’re smiling and thanking me.”

2. Distinguish pain from harm. Pain can be pleasurable, cathartic, and healing when consensual. Harm is non-consensual damage. Learn the difference in your bones.

3. Examine the source. Ask yourself: “Whose voice is this really?” Often it’s a parent, ex-partner, or cultural message that has no place in your consensual adult relationships.

4. Practice self-compassion statements. Replace “What’s wrong with me?” with “I’m exploring my authentic desires in a safe, consensual way.”

5. Keep a success journal. Document positive scenes, partner feedback, and moments of confidence. Review it when guilt strikes to remind yourself of reality.

“Consensual BDSM is not something to feel guilty about. It may take time to truly accept this at our core, but it’s worth pursuing.”

Strategy 4: Educate Yourself Out of Shame

Knowledge is power, and in this case, it’s also peace of mind. The more you understand about BDSM psychology, ethics, and physiology, the harder it becomes for shame to take root.

Your education checklist:

1. Learn the science of pain and pleasure. Understanding endorphins, neurochemistry, and why consensual pain can be positive helps rationalize your desires.

2. Study consent frameworks. Deep knowledge of SSC (Safe, Sane, Consensual) and RACK (Risk Aware Consensual Kink) provides an ethical foundation.

3. Read submissive perspectives. Books, blogs, and articles by submissives explaining why they crave what you provide can be incredibly validating.

4. Understand trauma-informed practices. Learning how to navigate scenes responsibly shows you’re engaging thoughtfully, not recklessly.

5. Explore the history of BDSM. Realizing these practices have existed across cultures and centuries normalizes them as part of human sexuality.

Strategy 5: Build Pre-Scene Confidence

Prevention beats cure. Building confidence before scenes can reduce the likelihood of post-scene guilt crashes.

Pre-scene practices that inoculate against guilt:

1. Negotiate thoroughly. A detailed negotiation where your partner enthusiastically consents gives you mental armor against later doubt.

2. Set intentions together. Discuss what you both want to achieve emotionally and physically. Shared goals create partnership, not victimization.

3. Use affirmations. Before scenes, remind yourself: “I’m providing an experience my partner desires. I’m skilled and careful. I deserve to enjoy this.”

4. Visualize success. Mental rehearsal of the scene going well, including happy aftercare, primes your brain for positive outcomes.

5. Check your headspace. If you’re already feeling guilty or ashamed before starting, postpone the scene and address those feelings first.

Strategy 6: Perfect Your Aftercare

Quality aftercare isn’t just for your submissive. You need it too, and it’s often the difference between integration and guilt spiral.

“Your partner returns to the room, smiling at first, but then puzzled when they sense the intimate magic has somehow soured.”

Aftercare strategies that support Dominants:

1. Build in processing time. Don’t rush the transition back to vanilla life. Give yourself space to come down from the intensity.

2. Ask for physical affection. If you need to be held, cuddled, or reassured, communicate that. Dominants need tenderness too.

3. Debrief together. Talk through what happened, how it felt, what worked. This converts the experience from “did I just do something terrible?” to “we created something beautiful together.”

4. Practice self-care rituals. Whatever helps you feel grounded—shower, favorite meal, journaling, meditation—make it part of your post-scene routine.

5. Avoid isolation. The worst thing you can do when guilt strikes is isolate yourself. Reach out to your partner, a friend in the community, or your support network.

Strategy 7: Celebrate Your Growth

Acknowledge your progress and growth as a Dominant by celebrating your successes and positive experiences. Embrace your achievements, whether it’s mastering a new technique, building trust with your partner, or creating memorable scenes. Recognizing your accomplishments can help reinforce that you are engaging in healthy, consensual activities that bring happiness and satisfaction to both you and your partner.

Ways to mark your progress:

1. Track skill development. Note when you master a new implement, learn better communication techniques, or successfully navigate a challenging scene.

2. Acknowledge emotional milestones. Celebrate the first time you enjoy a scene without guilt, or when you successfully talk yourself through a shame spiral.

3. Share wins with your community. Appropriate sharing of successes (respecting privacy) reinforces positive identity as a Dominant.

4. Reflect on trust built. The depth of trust your partner shows by submitting to you is worth celebrating. It means you’re doing something right.

5. Give yourself permission to enjoy. Your pleasure is not a moral failing. It’s a feature, not a bug, of consensual BDSM.

Finding Your Role Models

Find and connect with positive role models within the BDSM community, individuals who embody the values, ethics, and practices you admire. Learn from their experiences, insights, and advice, and strive to emulate their approach to kink. Surrounding yourself with positive influences can help dispel feelings of guilt or shame and provide reassurance that your desires and actions are not only valid but also embraced by others.

Look for Dominants who discuss their practice openly, who talk about consent and ethics, who clearly care about their submissives’ wellbeing. These role models show you what healthy dominance looks like and prove that you can embrace your sadistic or controlling desires without being a bad person.

“Even after years of engaging in ethical BDSM practices with clear consent, open communication, and honesty, residual guilt and shame can suddenly emerge.”

The Long Game: Patience and Self-Compassion

Finally, be patient and kind to yourself as you navigate your journey in the BDSM world. Overcoming feelings of guilt or shame may take time, and it’s essential to remember that growth and self-acceptance are ongoing processes. Treat yourself with compassion, and don’t be too hard on yourself when you experience setbacks or moments of doubt.

Top guilt doesn’t disappear overnight, especially if you’re deprogramming years of sex-negative messaging. Some days will be harder than others. You might have a scene that triggers old shame you thought you’d processed. That’s normal. That’s human. It doesn’t mean you’re failing.

The goal isn’t to never experience guilt again. The goal is to develop tools to recognize it, challenge it, and move through it without letting it poison your experience or your relationships.

If Top guilt or shame is hindering your growth and enjoyment as a Dominant, there’s no need to suffer in silence. Relief can often be found through the methods outlined above. Try these strategies, adapt them to your situation, and feel free to develop your own approaches that work for you.

By employing these strategies and remaining open to exploring new methods for addressing Top guilt, you can work towards embracing your desires and actions without guilt or shame. Consensual BDSM is a valid and rewarding aspect of many people’s lives, and with time and effort, you can fully accept and celebrate your role as a Dominant.

You’re not broken. You’re not sick. You’re a person with desires that, when expressed consensually and ethically, bring joy and fulfillment to yourself and your partners. That’s something worth protecting, nurturing, and yes, celebrating.

Related Articles

• BDSM Aftercare: Essential Guide to Post-Scene Care and Recovery (2024)
• Nurturing Bonds in Dominant/Submissive Dynamics
• Aftercare in Online Dom/Sub Relationships: Maintaining Connection and Care in the Virtual Sphere
• Power Dynamics and Aftercare in BDSM Relationships
• Mental Health and Aftercare: Nurturing Emotional Well-being in Dom/Sub Relationships